"The same number of days it took to create it!"
Oh dear. This film seems to be well liked. Sorry, but I'm about to give it quite the spanking. Oh, it looks good; the Martians and their craft look great. But this film is a badly written piece of crude religious propaganda with shockingly poor characterisation and hammy acting. Yes, I know it's a melodrama, but it isn't even amusing or gun to watch on a MST2000 kind of way. This is not the worst film I've seen all year, but it is the most disappointing.
Things start on a bad footing with Cedric Hardwicke, narrating and acting as the voice of H.G. Wells, giving us a tour of the Solar System that is shockingly inaccurate even for a time before space probes. Apparently Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune are not gas giants, Mercury is the only planet with no air, and Venus doesn't exist. Yes, that's right. They seem just to have forgotten it.
But then the film itself starts. And it gets worse. Oh, it's essentially just Wells' novel transplanted to McCarthy's America, but the film presents a grim picture of California in 1953, where the only thing to do on a Saturday night is a "square dance", whatever that is, with Coke instead of proper drink and, you know, fun. Life for these people can only improve under their new Martian overlords.
And then there's the stifling and crudely overdone Christian element, far too blatant to be a subtext. Now, I may be a Godless heathen myself, but I have no objection to religious subtexts in films. But this is about as subtle as a punch in the face- even the final defeat of the Martians by bacteria is portrayed as a divine miracle. And I get no sense of any true religious feeling; this is churchgoing as enforced respectability and conformity.
So... yeah. I didn't like this film much. Sorry. Still, I have high hopes for some of the films I have lined up...

You know, I actually found your take to be refreshing and interesting, especially as this is called one of the best films ever made. And even though many might don't agree with your opinion, you presented your case in such a calm, level-headed manner that even though I don’t know what to think of your thoughts on this film, I can't help but appreciate your open-minded look at this movie and many others and try to understand your criticisms. It's kind of amazing after reading this that you have an amazing blog on those films, and while not everyone, including myself, may always agree with your opions, you're really such a measured, rational guy.
ReplyDeleteAww, thank you, that's very kind!
ReplyDeleteI just really don't like heavy handed didacticism in general. It's not the message in itself, it's the crude way it's done- and this is not how one persuades!