Pages

Saturday, 17 May 2025

Doctor Who: The Interstellar Star Contest

 "You came back from the dead!"

"Sums up my career."

SPOILERS, obviously.

I'm not much of a one for light entertainment, so I wasn't sure I'd like this episode as much. I don't mean that as a criticism, mind: there hasn't been a dud this season so far, and Doctor Who bloody well should try and appeal well beyond middle aged geeky blokes like myself. Yet I thought it was brilliant, and not only because of that ending. But that we shall come to.

Despite this being an episode based on Eurovision (complete with not only Rylan Clark and Graham Norton, at last appearing in Doctor Who by actual design) and set in a space station, which is the most RTD thing ever, we have another new writer this week, which is brilliant.

Anyway, the opening is fun, with Belinda rather amusingly insisting that, yes, this time she actually wants to stay for a bit. Of course, given what we later learn, it's unclear how an Earth cultural institution could have become a spiral arm-wide phenomenon nine centuries later, but such things are easily handwaved. After all, there are nice little nuggets for the fans, such as star singer Cora ostensibly being from Trion, home planet of one Vizlor Turlough.

The threat, with the Hellions, is allowed to cleverly unfold, with a brilliant central performance from Freddie Fox as Kid. It's should make us uncomfortable that there will undoubtedly be parallels in our own world to the atrocities perpetrated by the Corporation upon the poor people of Hellia. Yet, while kid turns to mass murder, Cora instead turns to something both more positive and more effective- and there's a message for us all there in our oh so imperfect world. Blind, angry revenge is not the answer.

Mike and Gary are great as down-to-Earth audience identification characters- and I recognised Charlie Condou as Jonathan Yeah? from excellent sitcom Nathan Barley, in a minor little actor spotting triumph. But there's lots of good character stuff for the Doctor and Belinda, each separated and thinking the other dead, Belinda panicking about her situation and and realising she never got to tell the Doctor he was wonderful. This is an absolute acting triumph from Verada Sethu.

And then we have the Doctor going way too far in his attack on Kid, not so much the Time Lord Victorious but the Time Lord Damaged by Trauma. Ncuti Gatwa, too, is incredible here.

But... yeah. Let's talk about the big reveals, shall we? Susan- actually Carole Ann Ford- was a huge shock. She's only in the Doctor's head, but, with the little seeds planted last season, I'm sure she's out there... a Season 42 thing?

And then the Vindicator is finished, the Doctor can finally take Belinda home, but we get some exposition (from Graham Norton, who else?) telling us that Earth ceased to exist on 24th May 2024... and, as the TARDIS heads towards that date, the door blows off.

And that's all. Mrs Flood is indeed the Rani, which was unfortunately spoiled for me by the thumbnails of videos from inconsiderate YouTubers. But... a bi-generation? Archie Penjabi's Rani and Mrs Flood? Yeah, still processing that.

I definitely enjoyed this a lot. It may be a first viewing thing- watching this a second time without the big reveals may possibly be a different experience. But the episode works on its own terms, I think, with a nice subtext.

8 comments:

  1. Agreed about the Rani's bigeneration: it was entertaining, yes, but not earned dramatically. And I worry: this is a relaunch for new fans, RTD has said so, but... first, Sutekh, a one off villain from 1975. Now we have the Rani, from the pens of Pip and Jane Baker and the, er, delights of Dimensions in Time?

    I don't think Belinda is Susan. Non-diegetically, that would be a waste of Carole Ann Ford. May she live long, but she's 86. Make use of her talent- wasted back then- while she's still young enough.

    Susan is a Gallifreyan... is she necessarily a Time Lady?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SPOILERS BELOW FOR DW FINALE




      ....


      EDIT: [sigh]
      Well.
      Well, at least the Belinda/Susan rumours were just that, though it feels like a waste of Carole Ann Ford just appearing 5 seconds.
      But who seriously thought it to be a good idea to have the Doctor now use the face of a companion, someone who was even special to him?

      Delete
  2. Speaking of Susan, when are the writers going to bring back Jenny, portrayed by Georgia Tennant? She never was brought up since 2008,

    ReplyDelete
  3. Never, I suspect. The creation of a writer who did a couple of episodes and was never seen again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jenny did have some Big Finish audio adventures (and your mileage may vary on those) but that is it.

      Delete
    2. Ah yes, now you mention it I do recall seeing them reviewed in DWM. But, well, I hears a few of the more popular early Big Finishes, Spare Parts and the like.... but audio drama isn't going to be the favourite medium for a hard of hearing person :D

      Delete
  4. Stefan Mohamed, writing for Den of Geek, felt that the re-appearance of Susan was confusing to those not familiar with the series. Honestly, I think the issue with having Susan appear ramondly for one second as a vison is watchers KNOWING who she is and her significance. Only strong DW fans would know her character and considering the Doctor doesn't mention it to anyone, then I think it would have been seen as some random older lady appearing.

    Most People were excited to see how it would unfold in the final episode to see her finally reunited with The Doctor. Well guess what folks? It didn’t happen.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Agreed- and how many times has RTD done this sort of thing. Susan, but see also Sutekh and Omega, characters last seen in 1975 and 1983 respectively...

    ReplyDelete